HighFiveAffiliate.com - Your Internet Marketing Resource

A Call To Action

The Answer Isn’t Always More Traffic, It Could Be

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you. A huge amount of time is spent on research to make sure you have the best information, tips & strategies here. Hope you don’t mind a little reciprocation in return. Thanks!

You’ve got that blog. You’ve got that beautiful lead magnet. Or you’ve got some offer that they could buy. If only more people knew about it!

You’ve worked hard on creating your newest masterpiece. Your email list builder and lead magnet are in place and ready to convert visitors to subscribers. Problem is, your site visitors aren’t doing much for you right now. 

Am I right?

You need more traffic, more awareness. Well, that’s only part of the answer. 

Identifying The Real Problem

As a member of Wealthy Affiliate, I talk to other bloggers who are getting 1000+ monthly visitors through WA’s 24/7 online chat. I talk to experts and novices daily. A big topic is how to generate more traffic.

There may be another issue at play here that we are overlooking. The solution may lie not just in generating more traffic but in enticing your existing visitors to take ACTION.

The problem also lies in the fact that your current audience isn’t taking any action. 

  • They are not sharing your posts.
  • They are not opting in to grab your lead magnet.
  • They are not clicking on your affiliate links.
  • They are not buying.

So the real question is why not?

Maybe the answer lies more in how to get your site visitors to actually take some type of action. You need to define the moment of choice between inaction and action.

A call to action or CTA is a pretty well-known term in the marketing world. It tells your audience what to do and when. CTA is often presented as a button to subscribe to something or purchase something. Such as “Buy Now!”.

Call To Action Words

CTA can evoke enthusiasm with your audience to act quickly such as “buy one and get the second one free”. In this way, you’re offering a two for one deal. Who doesn’t like that? Make your audience feel lucky or special. 

  • Buy Now, Act Now, Order Today
  • Download Now, Featured, Exclusive
  • Find Out How, Get Your Copy Today, Instant Access

For example, you could say, “download our exclusive e-book now” or “become a member and gain instant access…”. Your website readers are looking for the “magic pill” that will solve their problems. Therefore, offer them something “unique” and “exclusive” they won’t find elsewhere.

You can also utilize scarcity or FOMO (fear of missing out) such as in “for a limited time only!”. When people believe this offer won’t come again, they are more likely to act quickly provided they are convinced of the value of your products. Some examples of this are:

  • Grab Yours Now While Supplies Last
  • Shop Today! Sale Ends Sunday
  • Be Transparent With Your Prices

Where To Include CTAs

Call to actions come in many different forms. They could be a simple link placed strategically within in your content or they could be placed in pop-ups, scroll boxes that come in from the right or left of the page, headers, footers, landing pages, emails, vides, webinar sign-ups, etc.

Use a variety of methods throughout your site and its content. When writing a blog, limit your CTAs to one per every 500 words so as not to overwhelm the reader.

Again, try switching things up like using a simple link in a paragraph and then further down using an opt-in form with an image. Both of them lead the reader to subscribe.

People don’t always respond to the same things. Those who are more visual by nature are more likely to respond to a link with an image than those who are more analytical.

You could use an opt-in form like the one below, giving readers just two choices. Alberta University used this approach to grow their email subscriber list 500%.

Build Landing Pages

Every person visiting your website is looking for something different whether that be new ideas, solutions or strategies. The more individual and personalized landing pages you can create, the wider your appeal will be. 

Think of a Chinese restaurant. They are catering to a specific set of people, namely those who like Chinese food. So, like a Chinese restaurant, the more you can offer your site visitors to choose from, the better. 

Make sure your landing pages address a specific need and link it to highly relevant posts only. 

Grab this $1.99 audiobook written by Fred Lam. Fred is A young visionary Fred Lam, who quite literally went from rags to riches; formerly a dishwasher, he has generated $20 million in revenue. In this audiobook he reveals the 5-step system he used and that allowed ordinary people just like you, quickly set up and launch e-commerce businesses in any niche making over $30 million in sales.

Transparency Builds Trust

Most of us today are pretty cynical. Nothing gets me doubting more quickly than when they don’t mention the price. Oftentimes, marketers feel they have to hide the price until after you’ve taken action. When I see this, after scrolling down the page looking for the price tag, it’s an instant red flag in my mind. 

Make sure your ads clearly display the pricing. This will help weed out the “just curious” from those who were not dissuaded by your price and are genuinely interested in your product.

Be upfront with your pricing AFTER you’ve justified its value to the audience. Give them pricing options such as a high, low and something in the middle.

Limit Their Choices

Oftentimes we think that the more products we offer the better the chances of a sale, but that’s not actually true. According to Barry Schwartz author of The Paradox of Choice, it has the opposite effect. Too many choices can often make people feel overwhelmed and unsure which leads to not making a choice at all and walking away. 

Instead, Schwartz suggests that paring down to just three clear choices actually increases the likelihood that a choice will be made. 

The Answer Isn't Always More Traffic, It Could Be - Set your email campaign on fire with this free e-course

There’s a method to put these three options together:

  • Make the first option a “no brainer” at minimal cost so they can try what you have to offer.
  • The second option should be super-deluxe with all the bells and whistles and at a premium price.
  • Lastly, the third option should be priced somewhere in the middle of the other two.


Don’t Ask…Tell

Remember “Show & Tell” when you were in school? Well, the same concept can be applied to your business, right? Show them how their lives will improve with your product/service and tell them what to do next.

Then show them another aspect of your product and how that will also improve get them closer to their goals. Then tell them what to do. The best landing pages use this exact strategy over and over.

This strategy can be very effective but will require the following:

  • That you know your customer’s goals and can speak to that directly
  • That you have a keen awareness of the challenges your customers face.
  • That you have a good understanding of what they really need vs what they want.

It’s important to you clearly lay out what your product/service can do for them and how their challenges are met, their goals achieved and ultimately their lives improved. Aim to build a clear picture in the mind of your customer of them actually using your product. Try to make it as detailed as possible.

Appeal To Their Identity

How does your perfect customer self identify? People take action with it conforms to their own self-image or role as a mother, father, doctor, mechanic, community activist, etc. So speak to that image directly such as…

“As local residents who love this community and want to see our young families flourishing here, you’ll want to donate to the refurbishment of this playground.”

There are other methods you can employ such as:

Social Proof – When something new comes on the scene few of us want to be the first to try it. Instead, we look for reviews from others who have tried it before us. Testimonials may help in that regard but only if you actually have them. Do not ever pay for a testimonial.

Offer A Bonus – Bonuses can often sway someone who is on the fence. So always make sure to offer one, two or three enticing bonuses with purchase.

Clear Instructions – Make sure there’s no confusion on what to do next. Give simple, clear instructions and tell them what will happen next.

Give Them Just A Taste – Oftentimes people aren’t fully ready to commit but will respond to a “taste” of what you have to offer. We see this strategy used all the time. 

  • When you have to provide an email address to get that free e-book or sign on to a free e-course.
  • Giving away a free course and then recommending an e-book purchase that will help them even further.
how to build and set up your email list free e-course

Wrapping It Up

In light of what we’ve just covered here today, take some time to look over your own site with a more objective view. Can you clearly identify the CTAs? Are you making a strong enough case for your product/service based on the customer’s needs and wants? There’s always room for improvement. Leave a question or comment below.

Your Two Cents

Which one of these strategies are you not utilizing enough of? Share your struggles and successes here.

Find Me On Pinterest

Hey, let’s meet up on Pinterest. I’ve made it super easy for you too! Just click on the image below and you’ll be taken to one of my boards devoted to growing an online business. See you there!

7 Replies to “The Answer Isn’t Always More Traffic, It Could Be”

  1. You are right. Having a lot of traffic to your website is great but I think the most important thing is the quality of your traffic. If there is a lot of traffic but you cannot convert that then there is no point in having them really. By applying your Call to Action strategy, you are most likely able to convert your audience. I think another important factor is to be persistent, don’t give up and make the audiences your friend and they will buy from you. Remember to help them and all things will fall into places. 🙂 

  2. Hi,

    Great piece of advice! Generating traffic to your site is crucial, but the ultimate goal is to make sales. If no sale are being made, then we need to do something about it.

    I think calls to action are a great way to approach it. However, I think creating a sense of urgency or scarcity is somewhat dishonest, don’t you think?

    It’s all about trust. If our readers don’t trust us, they won’t follow our advice regardless of how many strategies we employ.

    Thank you for your excellent recommendations. They come in handy for me.

    1. Absolutely! Urgency can be created by offering a limited time discount or added bonus. You can build up trust by offering some freebies, which in turn should help you grow your email list.

  3. Wow, that ’s great. The problems you said are also the problems I face because when I started to build a niche website last year to start an online business, visitors who visit my website rarely buy them. The conversion rate is very low.
    As you said in your blog post until later I took the time to optimize the website, using a lot of rules, such as establishing Landing Pages, adding Call To Action Words, limiting the choice of niche products as much as possible.
    Generally speaking, it’s the same way as you said in the post.

  4. Hi, I just wanted to say I enjoyed your article. It has some really useful information in it. I particularly like the part about offering bonuses and about CTAs. I think it’s very easy for people to click on a site, read and go and I’ve been struggling with that on my own website.

    I’ll give your suggestions a try. Thank you for such an informative piece.  I look forward to reading more from you. 

  5. Hey,

     I have learned a lot about how to run my website from now on. For the longest time, I think I’m missing something. Your article here actually inspired me to get back on track! I can really learn something from Don’t Ask…Tell. This is a difficult concept for me but I feel I can master it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *